I wrote this piece back in 1987. It’s a light-hearted commentary on the state of American education, linked to the beginning of construction on the English Channel tunnel. Despite the dated reference, its premise remains relevant, and I offer it here for whatever amusement (or satirical value) it might still have. I’ve attached a few bonus thoughts at the end.
HEY, LET’S NOT WASTE ALL THAT WASTE!
It’s not your everyday problem – how to get rid of 25 million cubic feet of chalk marl. But our friends, the French and English, are soon to confront it.
On December 1, they begin digging the long-awaited rail tunnel under the English Channel. By completion, a few years from now, they will have hauled up enough raw chalk to build the Great Pyramid of Egypt three times over.
Meanwhile, we in America have our own problem. We have high school seniors who can’t place World War I in the correct century. We have college freshmen who think Einstein invented the light bulb. For some reason, our kids aren’t learning the basic facts about their past.
Now, it’s clear what the French and English need. They need a process that consumes chalk – lots of it. It’s clear what we Americans need. We need a process that gets kids to remember basic facts. Question: Wasn’t there once a process that taught kids basic facts and consumed chalk?
Right, it was called Education.
As memory serves, it worked this way: Chalk would be shipped into classrooms in small boxes, the chalk shaped into solid, cigarette-like cylinders. These chalk cylinders differed from the felt-tip markers now in use. They didn’t dry out when you held them straight up. And the first one you grabbed worked. You didn’t have to try three or four others first.
Because they were easy to use, teachers would greatly encourage their use. When young Johnny would say, “Einstein? Like, um, didn’t he invent the light bulb?” – teacher would hand Johnny a cylinder of this chalk and send him to the chalkboard, where he would be encouraged to write a thousand times, “Edison invented the light bulb.”
In the process, five or six cylinders of chalk would be worked down to the nub. When the board was covered with scrawl, the teacher would say, “Now, Johnny, who invented the light bulb?” And Johnny would say, “Like, um, Edison?” And the teacher would say, “Good, Johnny, now erase the chalkboard and don’t forget to clap the erasers when you’re done.”
And young Johnny, after erasing the chalkboard, would lean out the classroom window and clap the erasers, sending clouds of chalk dust billowing into the ozone (We are only today finding out that the protective layer of ozone was always, chiefly, chalk dust.)
That’s how it worked. By converting five or six cylinders of chalk into chalk dust, a student would learn that Edison invented the light bulb. Chalk, in a word, was the solid fuel of education.
Now, the French and the English have well-chalked educational systems. They don’t need any more. Fact is, at great expense, they are planning to dispose of all this chalk marl by leveling old construction dumps, and filling in World War II bomb craters on the French coast, and reinforcing sea walls over by Dover.
What a waste of waste!
It’s likely that we Americans could have all that chalk for the asking, simply by providing transport. Think of it – 25 million cubic feet of chalk stoking those dormant furnaces of American education: our classrooms. It boggles the mind. It might even unboggle minds.
So France, England – send us the wretched refuse of your teeming shore (or offshore). We could use it.
Bonus Thoughts:
You wonder how many times the Creator has looked down on the human circus and said, , "You couldn't think this up."
"Know thyself, or at least keep renewing the acquaintance."
"I've concluded, after many years, that my mind works by process of elimination, although, as yet, it hasn't actually eliminated anything."
"What makes child-raising difficult is that each day you have to start with the child you have raised so far."
"You wonder if the nuclear holocaust that destroys one world is the Big Bang that starts the next."
"One thing you find when you consent to being a doormat -- they want you to say WELCOME."
"As a way to get to know new people, try giving a little more attention to the people you know."
"I have this theory: maybe, over millions of years, buried bones get larger by absorbing calcium from the earth's crust. Nah, dinosaurs make more sense."
~ Robert Brault
Monday, February 22, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

19 comments:
"I've concluded, after many years, that my mind works by process of elimination, although, as yet, it hasn't actually eliminated anything." Thanks Robert. I now see why I get hedged up from time to time.
I can't see the French (or the English) considering anything as magnanimous as giving the stuff away to help educate others. SELLING their waste to fund the project is the likely scenario.
LOVE the thought about getting to know the people you know as a way to get to know new people. There is so much going on in the world (a very noisy place in many respects)and our lives are so full and busy that we just don't take the time we should to really see and understand people who are already in our lives. Thank you!
"You wonder if the nuclear holocaust that destroys one world is the Big Bang that starts the next."
There may be more truth in this statement than we would care to know.
Ken,
Always happy to explain you to yourself. What do you suppose they did do with all that chalk marl -- just dump in back in the ocean?
Jan,
Yes, there are many ways to say it. Another way to get to know a new person is to read the blog of someone you've known all your life.
Marlene,
Agreed. And if what I wrote is the truth, I don't even care to know that much.
smiles all,
rb
You had me laughing right out loud with the doormat quote.
Welcome...I'm a doormat...
Have a great day.:)
Learning back in the days was something to pride over.
nowadays teachers are held down with a time-line to there throat threating if they dont smash our brains with all the info...weather it stays or not they risk losing money or there jobs.
meh.
nowadays theres to many ways to ESCAPE learning.i always loved class time where we went to the computer lab.teachers thought it was a better way to learn.i took it as a way to deceive...simple enough to open another tab with a teacher who has to manage 20 other kids thinking along the lines of what im thinking.
but then again im a straight forward thinker.i never liked school nor did good in it.not because im dumb.i simply dont believe in learning something that has nothing to to do with what i see as my own personal goal in life.
(if we were studying about the great "tea party" it would fly in 1 ear and out the other.because i saw no place for this kind of info to be used in my life or any job id take up.most adults replying with "you dont know what you could be doing in 10 years from now" to which i reply your right i dont.but knowing the person i am im 101% positive i still wont care for that info 10 years from now)
my mother calls this kind of thinking tunnel vision.you set everything else aside to reach 1 goal even if you set aside things you need to get to that goal.
Tis a curse and a blessing.
Hi!
This is a great essay, Robert...
I am reading two books this year for professional development. They both have some interesting new perspectives...but... they always come back around to 'the basics.' Practice and the acquisition of knowledge are building blocks.
Practice makes knowledge permanent and automatic. Then this becomes a building block for new and more more complex work.
~Amen~
The last time I saw my son's math homework was when he was in high school and I could still recognize a few things... now, Jason's atmospheric science and differential equations notes look like a foreign language.
He's certainly worn out several cases of 'chalk' laying down those building blocks!
~Maria
ps. Did you get snow today? We had over 17"
And, ohhh, was it heavy!
You've really chalked out the route of chalk...And oh boy do I remember when we had black-boards and not white boards; and chalk instead of markers. I was a teacher for a long time and I had my time with dry markers towards the latter half of my career...:)I like the idea of "renewing the acquaitance" with myself.
KC Mom, ShaneH, Maria, khushi
Thanks for comments. Pardon my silence. I'm away from home without the power hookup for my laptop and down to 15% power. Trying to conserve untl Saturday. Talk to you then.
smiles,
rb
I just found some of your quotes on a site called Quote Garden. I'm not normally a link follower, but I was interested in finding out who you were. I've read a few entries so far, and have been laughing quite a bit. You have a wonderful sense of humor and a quite a way with words.
"LOVE the thought about getting to know the people you know as a way to get to know new people. There is so much going on in the world (a very noisy place in many respects)and our lives are so full and busy that we just don't take the time we should to really see and understand people who are already in our lives. " Thanks Robert & Jan - Yours truly is on a brief visit to India - essentially catching up with family & friends - am trying to spend all the time possible with people I have known over the years - some of them for all of my life time !! Have visited few sacred places as well after 37 years !! A very important part of me is consists of the moments shared and steps covered !
KC Mom,
A laughing doormat? Well, I guess having people wiping their feet on you can tickle a bit.
ShaneH,
We're opposites, for a fact. I'm grateful for every bit of information that was ever pounded into my head, the less job-related the better. Life is all about knowing stuff.
Maria,
Congratulations to Jason. When the learning curve goes parabolic, it is a wonder to behold. Looks like Jason had a pretty good first teacher. (Yup, Albany is the snow capital on this one.)
khushi,
Yes, I still say "blackboard", causing my 9-year-old grandson to screw up his face in puzzlement.
Wendy,
Welcome. Glad you like. I prefer to have my thoughts referred to as "wisdom" rather than a "way with words," but my dad used to call them "Bob's squibs," so I can't complain.
Raj,
It sounds like quite an enterprise -- introducing the person you are to the person you were 37 years ago. It will be fascinating to see which person returns.
smiles all,
rb
hi thanks for such a nice post . chalk is most common thing that we uses in normal routine. By inhaling chalk dust we get disease
INHALATION: (Silica, Crystalline-Quartz)
Human: LCLo: 300 μg/m3 intermittent exposure over a 10-year period produced
pulmonary system effects.So preferably use marker in place of chalk
yours magazine,
I encourage all to heed your warning. I am immediately resigning my position as a bought and paid-for lobbyist for the chalk industry.
rb
Brault your effort is appreciable ! it also encouraged me .I will go to my nearby schools and institutions and suggest them to use marker in place of chalk . thanks for your response Robert .
Re this post: I suppose you'll just chalk this one up to experience. Me? I'll go out and dust the erasers. dk
Anon,
I guess I'm just a tool of Big Tobacco, Big Pharma and Big Chalk. You're right, I will chalk this one up to experience. There are all sorts out there.
smiles,
rb
I'm obviously very late to the party, but could not let this one slide. Absolutely love this post, although I have a stupid silly question (no, not what century was ww1); don't kids/teachers use chalk anymore?
Daisy,
well, I did think that schools long ago went to felt-tip markers, but "yours magazine" (above)obviously doesn't think so. I guess we;ll have to ask Maria.
smiles,
rb
Post a Comment